How HR Interviews Are Scored: Rubric by Level (2026)

A hr interview is scored on 4 dimensions: motivation and fit (30%), clarity on logistics (25%), professionalism (25%), compensation and negotiation (20%). Each is rated 1 to 4 against anchors that rise with the level. At mid level, an outstanding score on motivation and fit means: "Explains a clear career story where this role is the logical next step, with specifics."

The dimensions and their weights

DimensionWeightSolid (3) at mid level
Motivation and fit30%Gives a specific reason for this role and explains why the move makes sense now.
Clarity on logistics25%Clear on level, location, notice period and timeline, consistent with the resume.
Professionalism25%Composed, honest and positive about past roles, with no red flags.
Compensation and negotiation20%Handles compensation calmly with a reasoned range and asks about the full package.

What changes between levels

On motivation and fit, the heaviest dimension, an outstanding mid-level answer "explains a clear career story where this role is the logical next step, with specifics", while an outstanding senior answer "explains the impact they want to have here, grounded in the company's actual challenges". The same answer can score 4 at mid level and 2 at senior: senior candidates are expected to raise things unprompted that mid-level candidates may be asked about.

Every score, at every level

Motivation and fit (30%)

Level1 · Poor2 · Borderline3 · Solid4 · Outstanding
Intern / new gradCannot say why they want this company or role beyond "it is a good company".Gives a generic reason, such as brand name or salary, with nothing specific.Names a specific reason for this company and links it to a project or interest.Links specific facts about the company and role to their projects and career goals.
JuniorCannot say why they want this company or role.Gives a generic reason that would fit any company.Gives a specific, honest reason for this company and role.Gives a specific reason and connects it to their experience and next career step.
Mid-levelCannot say why they want this company or role.Gives a generic reason, or focuses only on leaving the current job.Gives a specific reason for this role and explains why the move makes sense now.Explains a clear career story where this role is the logical next step, with specifics.
SeniorCannot say why they want this company or role.Gives a reason focused on title or pay, with little about the work.Explains what they want to build or own here and why their experience fits.Explains the impact they want to have here, grounded in the company's actual challenges.
StaffCannot say why they want this company or role.Gives a reason focused on title or pay, with little about the work.Explains the organisational problems they want to take on and why they fit.Explains a clear thesis about the company's direction and the role they would play in it.

Clarity on logistics (25%)

Level1 · Poor2 · Borderline3 · Solid4 · Outstanding
Intern / new gradGives contradictory answers on relocation, shifts, bond or joining date.Answers logistics questions vaguely, such as "I will see" about relocation or a bond.Gives clear answers on relocation, shifts, service bond and graduation date.Answers clearly, including higher-studies plans, and asks a sensible question about joining.
JuniorGives contradictory answers on location, notice period or joining date.Answers vaguely and needs repeated questions to pin down notice or location.States notice period, location preference and joining date clearly and consistently.States logistics clearly and raises any constraint, such as a pending offer, upfront.
Mid-levelGives contradictory answers on location, notice period or joining date.Answers logistics vaguely or leaves out a known constraint.Clear on level, location, notice period and timeline, consistent with the resume.Clear on all logistics and states other processes and deadlines honestly upfront.
SeniorGives contradictory answers on location, notice period or joining date.Answers logistics but is unclear on the level or scope they expect.Clear on level, scope, location and timeline, with constraints stated upfront.Clear on all logistics and frames competing timelines so both sides can plan.
StaffGives contradictory answers on location, notice period or joining date.Answers logistics but is unclear on the level or scope they expect.Clear on level, scope, team expectations, location and timeline.Clear on all logistics and sets out what they need to make a decision, and by when.

Professionalism (25%)

Level1 · Poor2 · Borderline3 · Solid4 · Outstanding
Intern / new gradSpeaks badly of their college or peers, or gives answers that contradict the resume.Answers honestly but casually, with long rambles or one-word replies.Answers politely, honestly and consistently with the resume.Answers politely and concisely, handles an awkward question such as a backlog with candour.
JuniorSpeaks badly of a past employer, or gives answers that contradict the resume.Answers honestly but rambles or sounds defensive on a gap or change.Composed, honest and consistent with the resume throughout.Composed and candid, and explains a gap or short stint briefly without defensiveness.
Mid-levelSpeaks badly of a past employer, or gives answers that contradict the resume.Mostly composed but defensive or vague on a difficult question.Composed, honest and positive about past roles, with no red flags.Composed and candid on difficult questions, and asks thoughtful questions in return.
SeniorSpeaks badly of a past employer, or gives answers that contradict the resume.Professional but evasive on reasons for leaving or a difficult episode.Composed, candid and positive, handling difficult questions with brief, honest answers.Handles every difficult question with candour and keeps the conversation two-way.
StaffSpeaks badly of a past employer, or gives answers that contradict the resume.Professional but evasive on reasons for leaving or a difficult episode.Composed and candid, and discusses past organisations fairly and constructively.Handles every difficult question with candour and treats the call as a mutual evaluation.

Compensation and negotiation (20%)

Level1 · Poor2 · Borderline3 · Solid4 · Outstanding
Intern / new gradRefuses to discuss pay, or accepts any terms without understanding them.Names an unrealistic figure, or says "anything is fine" when asked about pay.Accepts a campus package or stipend politely and asks one clarifying question about it.Asks clear questions about the package, bond or stipend and responds calmly to the answers.
JuniorRefuses to discuss pay, or reacts badly to the question.Names a figure with no basis, or reveals current pay in a way that anchors low.Handles the pay question calmly and gives a reasonable range when asked.Gives a researched range with a reason and keeps room to discuss the full offer.
Mid-levelRefuses to discuss pay, or reacts badly to the question.Gives a number without reasoning, or anchors badly against the market.Handles compensation calmly with a reasoned range and asks about the full package.Defers specifics until the level is clear, then gives a researched range with reasons.
SeniorRefuses to discuss pay, or reacts badly to the question.Gives a range but cannot justify it, or negotiates only on base pay.Gives a researched range tied to level and scope, and discusses the whole package.Negotiates calmly on the whole package, using competing timelines without ultimatums.
StaffRefuses to discuss pay, or reacts badly to the question.Gives a range but cannot justify it, or negotiates only on base pay.Ties expectations to level, scope and market data, and discusses the whole package.Negotiates level, scope and package together, calmly and with clear reasons.

Get scored against this rubric

Thita's AI interviewer runs a live hr round and scores you against exactly this rubric, dimension by dimension, for the level you choose.

Practise an HR round

Where this rubric comes from

These rubrics are researched: they follow the scoring methods big-tech companies describe publicly (behaviourally anchored ratings, bar raisers, leadership principles, named interview signals) and how their rounds are commonly run. No company publishes its actual scoring sheet, so the level-by-level wording is our own synthesis. It is the same rubric our AI interviewer scores every mock against.

Questions, answered

How is a hr interview scored?
A hr interview is scored on 4 dimensions: motivation and fit (30%), clarity on logistics (25%), professionalism (25%), compensation and negotiation (20%). Each is rated 1 to 4 against anchors that rise with the level. At mid level, an outstanding score on motivation and fit means: "Explains a clear career story where this role is the logical next step, with specifics."
What is the difference between a mid-level and a senior hr answer?
On motivation and fit, the heaviest dimension, an outstanding mid-level answer "explains a clear career story where this role is the logical next step, with specifics", while an outstanding senior answer "explains the impact they want to have here, grounded in the company's actual challenges". The same answer can score 4 at mid level and 2 at senior: senior candidates are expected to raise things unprompted that mid-level candidates may be asked about.
What does a score of 3 mean?
Scores are relative to the level you are interviewing for. A 3 means solid for that level: the bar is met without help on the key points. A 4 means the candidate also raised the important points unprompted. A 2 usually means the interviewer had to lead the candidate to them.
Is this the official rubric used by Google, Meta or Amazon?
These rubrics are researched: they follow the scoring methods big-tech companies describe publicly (behaviourally anchored ratings, bar raisers, leadership principles, named interview signals) and how their rounds are commonly run. No company publishes its actual scoring sheet, so the level-by-level wording is our own synthesis. It is the same rubric our AI interviewer scores every mock against.